REVEREND J.J. MOTT (1867-1877)

REVEREND GEORGE S. SMITH (First black Pastor 1877-1900)

REVEREND DR. CURTIS WHITE

REVEREND JENNINGS (1901-1902)

REVEREND H. E. KING

REVEREND T. M. NIXON

REVEREND F. B. MALLARD

REVEREND PERFECT R. DEBERRY (1910-1925)

REVEREND D. J. FLYNN (1926-1928)

REVEREND E. C. LAWRENCE (1932-1951)

REVEREND HOWARD CUNNINGHAM (1952-1972)

REVEREND DONALD R. INGRAM, SR (1973–2014)

REVEREND DR. MICHAEL R. SMITH, SR. (2017-2022)

INTERIM, REVEREND DR. PAULETTE KEARNEY (2024-2025)

REVEREND DR. J. ALEXANDER LEASTON (2025 – PRESENT)